by Jem Smith » 29 Oct 2024, 08:55
Fergal wrote:Jem Smith wrote:I'm not down with a lot of Buddhist beliefs either
Jem Smith do you mind me asking which Buddhist beliefs you don't believe in?
Karma. Some Buddhists are unsympathetic/unkind to people with disabilities (for example) because they believe they deserve their difficulties because of something they did in a past life.
And stuff like this (from an article about a Buddhist school)
'Nowhere was this more in evidence than in the ramifications of the belief in karma. At first glance, karma is a lovely idea which encourages people to be good even when nobody is watching for the sake of happiness in a future life. It's a bit carrot-and-stickish, but so are a lot of the ways in which we get people to not routinely beat us up and take our stuff. Where it gets insidious is in the pall that it casts over our failures in this life. I remember one student who was having problems memorising material for tests. Distraught, she went to the monks who explained to her that she was having such trouble now because, in a past life, she was a murderous dictator who burned books, and so now, in this life, she is doomed to forever be learning challenged.Not, "Oh, let's look at changing your study habits", but rather, "Oh, well, that's because you have the soul of a book-burning murderer."
To our ears, this sounds so over the top that it is almost amusing, but to a kid who earnestly believes that these monks have hidden knowledge of the karmic cycle, it is devastating. She was convinced that her soul was polluted and irretrievably flawed, and that nothing she could do would allow her to ever learn like the people around her...
And this is the dark side of karma – instead of misfortunes in life being bad things that happen to you, they are manifestations of a deep and fundamental wrongness within you. Children have a hard enough time keeping up their self-esteem as it is without every botched homework being a sign of lurking inner evil.'
https://newhumanist.org.uk/articles/4021/the-dark-side-of-buddhismAnd I have issue with the goal of life being to reject things of the world. I don't think earthly pleasures are a bad thing.
Also the hypocrisy of causing violence while preaching non violence (using hate speech against muslims).
https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32929855
[quote="Fergal"][quote="Jem Smith"]I'm not down with a lot of Buddhist beliefs either[/quote]
Jem Smith do you mind me asking which Buddhist beliefs you don't believe in?[/quote]
Karma. Some Buddhists are unsympathetic/unkind to people with disabilities (for example) because they believe they deserve their difficulties because of something they did in a past life.
And stuff like this (from an article about a Buddhist school)
'Nowhere was this more in evidence than in the ramifications of the belief in karma. At first glance, karma is a lovely idea which encourages people to be good even when nobody is watching for the sake of happiness in a future life. It's a bit carrot-and-stickish, but so are a lot of the ways in which we get people to not routinely beat us up and take our stuff. Where it gets insidious is in the pall that it casts over our failures in this life. I remember one student who was having problems memorising material for tests. Distraught, she went to the monks who explained to her that she was having such trouble now because, in a past life, she was a murderous dictator who burned books, and so now, in this life, she is doomed to forever be learning challenged.Not, "Oh, let's look at changing your study habits", but rather, "Oh, well, that's because you have the soul of a book-burning murderer."
To our ears, this sounds so over the top that it is almost amusing, but to a kid who earnestly believes that these monks have hidden knowledge of the karmic cycle, it is devastating. She was convinced that her soul was polluted and irretrievably flawed, and that nothing she could do would allow her to ever learn like the people around her...[b]And this is the dark side of karma – instead of misfortunes in life being bad things that happen to you, they are manifestations of a deep and fundamental wrongness within you.[/b] Children have a hard enough time keeping up their self-esteem as it is without every botched homework being a sign of lurking inner evil.'
[url]https://newhumanist.org.uk/articles/4021/the-dark-side-of-buddhism[/url]
And I have issue with the goal of life being to reject things of the world. I don't think earthly pleasures are a bad thing.
Also the hypocrisy of causing violence while preaching non violence (using hate speech against muslims).
[url]https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32929855[/url]