Website Hosting for Just 20 ForumCoin ~ Advertise on ForumCoin
ForumCoin is an online community where you earn ForumCoin for making posts and for referring other members. You can use the ForumCoin virtual currency to buy and sell goods and services and to exchange for traditional currencies. Find out more!
Ad Banner
Cinema, Television, Literature, Music and Entertainment

Book vs Movie -changes

Postby Netherrealmer » 17 Sep 2021, 15:23

Whenever a Book is adapted into a movie or a tv series, usually producers do some liberties because of what their budget can handle or how liberal or conservative the book was written.

Here are some movies that are very different from the book.

Breakfast at Tiffany's- Considered as one of the best romance movies of all time but the source material is not a romance.
Image


The movie is about a writer who have writer's block who fell in love with an Escort girl. He loved her for who she is and saved her from the life of prostitution. Well any man will fall in love with someone who looks like Audrey Hepburn, she plays a prostitute on this movie and she still looks classy.

In the book, The writer is Gay! and his relationship with the woman is not romantic. It is about friendship between a Gay man and a woman who is rejected by society. When it got adapted into a movie, they turn him straight and turn the friendship into romance.

I know what you did last summer


Image
In the movie a group of teenagers drove under the influence and they accidentally hit a man. They thought he is dead so they throw away his body in the ocean. Little did they know he survived and he wanted revenge. He will them one by one.

Image

In the book their car hits a child, and they buried the body. The father of the child tried to find them one by one to kill them.

-----------
IT
Image

The movie is about a group of children called the losers, The losers are being haunted by Pennywise, A killer clown entity who eats and kill children.In the movie after killing Pennywise the children made a blood pack so they can escape his world.

In the book they had sex so they will lose their innocence because as long as they are innocent they will be stuck on his realm.... I am so happy the movie never followed the novel.

---
  • 1

User avatar
Netherrealmer
Community Moderator
 
Posts: 36,723
Location: Babylon
Reputation: 5128
ForumCoin: 1,186



Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby cmoneyspinner » 21 Sep 2021, 10:01

LOL. :lol: I have to say that you are absolutely right. Audrey Hepburn always looks classy!
  • 0

User avatar
cmoneyspinner
 
Posts: 18,531
Location: Texas USA
Referrals: 10
Reputation: 3902
ForumCoin: 1,542

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby ptrikha21 » 07 Nov 2021, 15:50

I have seen some Movies that were an adaptation of books. In some cases, I saw Movies first and then read the book.
Like "3 Idiots" movie first and then the book "Five Point Someone" - Chetan Bhagat.
Also, "Murder on the Orient Express".
Now, in some cases, there were changes. Like extra action scenes, or extra drama (especially Bollywood).
Then, in Hollywood, I see emphasis on some characters more than those in the book.
It does keeps on varying.
  • 1

User avatar
ptrikha21
 
Posts: 6,743
Location: India
Referrals: 5
Reputation: 1300
ForumCoin: 715

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby Netherrealmer » 08 Nov 2021, 05:11

cmoneyspinner wrote:LOL. :lol: I have to say that you are absolutely right. Audrey Hepburn always looks classy!
I wonder how a story about the friendship between a gay man and a prostitute lady ends up being romance in the Adaptation. Some film analist think he is also Gay in the movie but Audrey Hepburn's character cured him. :lol:
  • 0

User avatar
Netherrealmer
Community Moderator
 
Posts: 36,723
Location: Babylon
Reputation: 5128
ForumCoin: 1,186

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby peachpurple » 11 Dec 2021, 09:34

I had read many thai boy love novels which are different from the movies. Directors changed the script and plots a better ending where viewers are keen to watch. Mostly are happily ever after endings
  • 0

User avatar
peachpurple
 
Posts: 6,201
Location: Singapore
Referrals: 2
Reputation: 490
ForumCoin: 364

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby ptrikha21 » 12 Dec 2021, 10:05

peachpurple wrote:I had read many thai boy love novels which are different from the movies. Directors changed the script and plots a better ending where viewers are keen to watch. Mostly are happily ever after endings


Looks similar to what we have in Bollywood where most movies based on novels used to had good endings.
However, in the recent years, I have seen some movies with a not so happy endings and supposedly "Realistic endings" !
  • 0

User avatar
ptrikha21
 
Posts: 6,743
Location: India
Referrals: 5
Reputation: 1300
ForumCoin: 715

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby eldavis » 12 Dec 2021, 17:06

Over the years I have seen some movie adaptations of novels and some where good, some where not just up to taste. I guess the budget in most cases is usually not enough to add most parts
  • 0

eldavis
 
Posts: 5,057
Location: Nigeria
Referrals: 6
Reputation: 166
ForumCoin: 94

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby GuestHu » 26 Dec 2021, 04:44

I find nothing wrong if they made a movie from a novel and change its storyline. What I despise is ruining the good original story. If they want to adapt it, make sure they will make its story better than the original.
  • 1

User avatar
GuestHu
 
Posts: 1,402
Reputation: 239
ForumCoin: 749

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby ptrikha21 » 19 Feb 2022, 15:47

eldavis wrote:Over the years I have seen some movie adaptations of novels and some where good, some where not just up to taste. I guess the budget in most cases is usually not enough to add most parts


At times, Novels are long and movies have to shorten things. Plus some characters are wither added to spice up things or some removed.
Sometimes, it makes movies better or as good as the novel; and worse some other times.
  • 0

User avatar
ptrikha21
 
Posts: 6,743
Location: India
Referrals: 5
Reputation: 1300
ForumCoin: 715

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby Hilda » 25 Apr 2022, 08:30

I have also heard other people say that, I don't like reading novels so I can't be able to compare if it the story changes in the movie. I have never been able to finish reading a novel, I just prefer watching the movie.
  • 0

Hilda
 
Posts: 449
Referrals: 1
Reputation: 28
ForumCoin: 6

Re: Book vs Movie -changes

Postby Dora Wi » 07 May 2022, 06:02

Lately I've been wondering if "based on the book XYZ" in the case of Netflix originals really means "loosely inspired by some parts of the book XYZ" lmao
For example, I both read and watched Tiny Pretty Things and apart from the personality of a few characters and a few main events, the whole storyline goes in a completely different direction.
  • 1



Last bumped by Netherrealmer on 07 May 2022, 06:02.
Check out the latest forecasts and news about cryptocurrencies, stocks, forex pairs and more on WalletInvestor.com
Dora Wi
 
Posts: 314
Reputation: 34
ForumCoin: 132



Your Ad Here.

Return to Pop Culture



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron
Reputation System ©'